Digital valuations rival physical inspections in new study

23 November 2026
Share this article
Digital valuations rival physical inspections in new study

A new study of more than 1 million lending records has found that digital valuations deliver results comparable with physical inspections.

The research from property data analytics provider Cotality compared automated valuation models (AVMs), valuer-led digital assessments and full physical inspections against a benchmark full inspection.

The findings found that just 4 percentage points separated the four valuation methods at the +10 per cent benchmark, with digital property valuation service SMARTval recording the highest result.

Digital valuations close the gap

 
 

Cotality’s SMARTval recorded the strongest result, with 80 per cent of valuations falling within 10 per cent of the benchmark. This compared with 78 per cent for separate full inspections, 77 per cent for IntelliVal AVMs and 76 per cent for Cotality Desktop.

The research also highlighted that two separate physical inspections did not necessarily produce the same result, with 78 per cent of separate full inspections falling within 10 per cent of the benchmark after adjusting for market movement.

Carl Pinto, director of banking and finance at Cotality, said the findings could help lenders determine when a digital valuation was appropriate and when a physical inspection was required.

“The question isn’t whether digital valuations should replace physical inspections. It’s how to choose the right valuation pathway for the property, the borrower and the lending decision,” he said.

He said the research provided lenders with a stronger evidence base for considering faster digital pathways, perhaps where property and risk settings allowed.

md discover

“That matters because every unnecessary step in the lending process can add time. The opportunity is to remove friction where we can, without compromising prudent lending.”

Strongest results for mid-priced properties

The research found valuation performance was strongest for properties valued between $500,000 and $1 million, which accounted for around 57 per cent of the dataset.

For properties valued between $500,000 and $700,000, SMARTval recorded 83 per cent of assessments within 10 per cent of the benchmark, compared with 82 per cent for AVMs, 80 per cent for full inspections and 79 per cent for Desktop valuations.

In the $700,000 to $1 million bracket, SMARTval recorded 84 per cent, while full inspections achieved 82 per cent and both AVMs and Desktop valuations recorded 81 per cent.

Pinto said the results reinforced the importance of lenders avoiding a one-size-fits-all approach to valuation policy.

“The strongest results were concentrated across the $500,000 to $1 million property bands, which represented a substantial share of the lending records studied.

“As property values increased, we saw greater variation between valuation methods. For a lender, that’s useful information.

“It helps build a more nuanced valuation strategy based on the property, the available market evidence and the lender’s own risk appetite, rather than simply applying the same process to every application,” he said.

Physical inspections remain important

Pinto said the findings did not mean physical valuations should be removed from the lending process, with professional valuers continuing to play an important role in both full inspections and digital assessments.

“This isn’t about making every valuation digital, and it certainly isn’t about removing professional valuers from the process. Valuers remain integral to full inspections as well as valuer-led digital assessments,” he said.

He said the opportunity was to use the research to better match the valuation approach to the lending scenario.

“The real opportunity is giving lenders better evidence to determine when an application can take a faster path and when the circumstances warrant a deeper assessment.

“If lenders can make that distinction with greater confidence, there’s an opportunity to improve turnaround times while maintaining the risk discipline that sits at the heart of responsible lending,” Pinto said.

Cotality said the analysis used anonymised lending activity across a rolling two-year dataset, matching assessments of the same property against a benchmark full inspection and adjusting for market movement between valuation dates.

The measure assessed how closely each valuation aligned with the benchmark. It did not measure accuracy against a subsequent property sale price.

SMARTval recorded the highest overall result across all three benchmarks but had the smallest sample size. Cotality said the findings should therefore not be interpreted as showing it was inherently more accurate than the other methods.

[Related: New Victoria auction rules reshape pre-approval equation]

Broker DailyWant to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Broker Daily a preferred news source on Google.
Tags: